Number 299 – October 11, 2010
Dear Masonic Student,
Here is another fine column from Dr. and Brother Stan Shapiro.
On Deciding to Lie or Not
By Stan Shapiro, LEO
As Masons we take pride in honesty. In our discussions we have noted Masons, like all people, sometimes tell “white lies”. We concluded “white lies” are sometimes appropriate if they were told to spare another person’s feelings. I now believe another condition for a lie to be “white “if the person will gain nothing for himself by telling it.
A new study at Harvard University by Joshua Green found that honest people don’t need to worry about being led into temptation to lie. He and his colleagues investigated whether honesty is an act of will or inherent grace. They scanned the brains of 25 people who were told they would receive a monetary reward if they could correctly predict the outcome of a coin toss. Sometimes the participants had to call out loud as the coin was tossed and sometimes they were asked after the toss what they had guessed. A control group of participants always said their prediction out loud and thus had no opportunity to cheat.
As you would expect, the control group accurately predicted heads or tails 50 percent of the time.
The group that had the opportunity to cheat was correct 66 percent of the time with some participants “predicting “heads or tails with 90 percent accuracy: When these participants chose not to lie, the scans of their brain showed activity in the prefrontal lobe, which is the area used in making decisions. Non-cheaters, who always told the truth, lacked this activity. Post-experiment interviews confirmed that the honest people were aware of the opportunity to cheat. Thus the research team concluded, “When it comes to honesty, it seems more grace than will.”
Does this mean that as Mason’s we are honest more by grace than having to think about whether we will be honest first?
Words to live by: “Honesty is the best policy.” Most worshipful Brother Benjamin Franklin
To view and participate in this week’s Masonic Monday Question, please go to http://www.lodgebuilder.org and click on the Lodge Education forum, or http://halpaus.blogspot.com/ When you have an answer, send it to email@example.com The Masonic Monday Question for the week of 10-11-10 is: What can you tell a non-Mason about Freemasonry?
More Light – Mehr Licht ©, Masonic Matters © and T.F.S. ©, are sent out by Email at no charge to anyone who would like to receive them. If you enjoy these publications please share them with others. To subscribe or unsubscribe to these publications just send an E-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org with Subscribe or unsubscribe in the subject line and I will take care of your request.
Ed’s Blog and new Web Site contain some articles and papers by Ed, as well as other Masonic information useful to the Masonic Student and researcher. More information is added on a regular basis. The URL’s are: http://halpaus.blogspot.com and http://sites.google.com/site/edsmasonicmatters/
The Education Videos of the Grand Lodge of Minnesota can be viewed at: http://www.youtube.com/glmned
If you are receiving duplicates of these emails please let me know which email addresses you receive the duplicate at, and I’ll remove that email address to the distribution list: To unsubscribe or to subscribe and for other changes send an email to email@example.com and I’ll take care of it for you.
It’s Masons who make Freemasonry relevant in their community!